Choose the tuxedo, four years later…

Kelli Davis Thanks to Amy Stiefvater for pointing me to this story of a girl refused when she wanted to wear a tuxedo to her prom. This is ridiculous. What year is it? 2009?

HAVEN'T WE GOT MORE IMPORTANT THINGS TO DO THAN LEGISLATE CLOTHING?

Amy tells me that already people have started responding to the news story in hate, saying the girl is perverted and evil (the girl who wants to wear a tux is a lesbian). I wrote in 2005 about a similar situation – we are sadly no further along, evidently.

Go rent a tux, wear it all week, read my earlier post on this because it might be helpful, and then send a note to the high school principal in support of this student's right to wear a tux, if you would. Please be civil and respectful – I've learned that telling people they are idiots and expecting them to listen is not a good strategy (I know that's hard to believe, but trust me on this one):

http://www.leb.k12.in.us/lhs/
Kevin O'Rourke – orourkek@leb.k12.in.us (UPDATE – I got an error message sending to this email address – can you let me know if your email went through? If not, can you call his office?)
or give him a ring: 765-482-0400

or fax your note (Fax? what's that?) to: 765-483-3040

Also, please copy or call the central office:

Lebanon Administration Offices
1810 N. Grant St. :: Lebanon, IN 46052
Phone (765) 482 – 0380 :: Fax (765) 483 – 3053

Here's what I'm sending him, in case it's helpful – feel free to cut and paste and alter as you'd like:

Dear Principal O'Rourke,

I am writing to you from Asheville, North Carolina, where I live with my husband and two girls, one of whom is a junior in high school. I have great respect for the difficulty of any school administrator and so I am writing from a viewpoint of great admiration for the work you do.

I have recently heard of the decision in your school to ban girls wearing tuxedos to their prom. This troubles me, and although I don't have a child in your school, I felt compelled to write.

My intention in writing is to ask you to reconsider your decision by exploring the rationale beneath it. I understand the need for dress codes in school and I also know from experience that legislating behavior and dress in any high school is tough work. Yet, if there is not mention of gender specific clothing or tuxedos in your dress code, I'm unsure why your decision was made or how it can be enforced.

But I'm not interested, really, in enforcement. My concern is that because this student is a lesbian, you are making a decision that might not be made otherwise. The tenor of the hate mail directed at the newspaper articles about this story would indicate a community with much work to do in order to be inclusive of gay and lesbian community members.

Surely you understand that any child who is gay, lesbian, or transgender may have added difficulty in their school life than their straight peers simply because they are not in the dominant culture. To add to that difficulty with what seems a capricious decision seems cruel to me. I would urge you to consider that what a student wears to the prom, if it is within the realm of decency, is less important than graduating students who can’t read and write, don’t know enough math to balance a checkbook, and who are doing drugs in the school bathrooms. I know you know this.

I hope you will reconsider, not from a legal perspective, but from a human one. If I can help, don't hesitate to contact me.

Best regards,

Patti Digh

Please leave a comment below if you're able to send a note. I'd love for him to hear from people all over the world. Today.

(photo is of Kelli Davis who challenged her school's senior picture policy in 2005)

About Patti Digh

Patti Digh is an author, speaker, and educator who builds learning communities and gets to the heart of difficult topics. Her work over the last three decades has focused on diversity, inclusion, social justice, and living and working mindfully. She has developed diversity strategies and educational programming for major nonprofit and corporate organizations and has been a featured speaker at many national and international conferences.

12 comments to " Choose the tuxedo, four years later… "
  • Amy

    I already sent a note. As a teacher, I can’t believe that a school would willingly discriminate against a student who is (seemingly, according to comments) struggling to be accepted. I wish that brave student the best, and courage for the administrator to make the best choice in the face of a difficult decision in a community not yet willing to accept this member.

  • Kathy

    I’m really irritated that we focus so much energy on such simple things – a tux. A simple expression of self. rgh.

    Thanks for sending the good word, around. Would love to think of a way to show the girl some support, as well. Will write though.

  • Ashley

    Here is the letter I sent today! SPEAK UP EVERYONE!

    Dear Principal O’Rourke,

    My name is Ashley Kite and I am writing to you from San Diego, California. Upon hearing of your decision to ban girls wearing tuxedos to their own prom, I felt compelled to write and ask for your reconsideration on your students’ behalf in regard to the ban of tuxedos worn by young girls.
    As someone who is not too far outside of her own high school years, I look back and remember that what one chooses to wear to prom is one more avenue of self-expression. I have had friends who chose to wear Converse sneakers with their gowns, pantsuits, or any other combination. I understand the need for dress codes when it comes to matters of decency and overexposure, which many teenagers are all too guilty of, but a tuxedo is simply a matter of self-expression and of, perhaps, stating that women can be feminine and beautiful regardless of their attire. Many of the world’s most beautiful women have shown up to public events wearing gorgeous pantsuits and tuxedos by the world’s top designers and they are always considered a striking contrast to the customary dress.
    What she chooses to wear to HER prom should be less of a concern than is she a good person, has she succeeded in school to be able to attend the event. And mostly, we should be grateful that this young girl has the courage to think for herself in choosing her attire, in determining what she thinks is beautiful and if that is different from what is expected of girls, this is the United States where THANKFULLY women are free to choose how they want to dress in public. Her choice is so conservative, I have to believe you have made an error in choosing to exclude her and hope you will quickly reconsider. Let her be an example to all of your students that her right to self-expression when done tastefully, is something to be admired, not something to be shut out.
    There are so many other pressing issues in our world right now. What a young girl wears to her prom is a personal decision, not a political one, and should be left to her to decide how she wants to look back on that moment in her life. I sincerely ask that you reconsider your decision and help set an example of respect and inclusion and put this in perspective. It is a girl and her prom at the close of her high school years. There are so many other obstacles awaiting her in this life, please let her last moments of adolescence be a time of wonder and excitement, rather than one filled with sadness and isolation.
    We would all hope to have someone compassionate to come to our aide if it were our daughter/sister/friend facing the same treatment .I hope you will be that person and reconsider.
    Sincerely,
    Ashley Kite
    San Diego, California

  • Elizabeth

    Interestingly enough, I wasn’t able to load their webpage either. I sincerely hope it’s a sign that they are reconsidering their decision.

  • We have a girly-girl and a not-so-girly-girl, who may one day decide to wear a Tux to her senior prom. I hope that by that time, seven years from now, that that choice will be just another outfit from which to choose.

    We have been, and we will remain active in our schools – right now it’s middle school and primary school. I believe that we can help change things if we are ACTIVE (as in life is a verb?) in ensuring that change.

    Our presence in the schools has opened our community’s eyes to the existence of other walks of life like our own – and we won’t be silenced because of rules that make no sense.

    momma deb

  • Cindy

    Questions:

    DOES one has to be a lesbian to wear a tux?? OR does one wearing a tux is a lesbian?

    IF both answers are YES. Then we have to ask women to take off their jeans! I would think jeans is equally guilty as a tux.

  • jylene

    at my junior prom, there was a group of senior girls who showed up in matching tuxedos and they looked so cool! my boyfriend didn’t want to attend my senior prom so i didn’t plan on going– until i found out there was a group of girls going in tuxedos. i knew them, but they weren’t in my circle, so i spoke with the one i knew best. it turned out there were 5 of them and the school was making them purchase tickets for 6 (three couples) so they were looking for someone to join them. there i was, at the last minute, looking for a tux– and i had a blast! seven years later, my sister and her best friend attended her prom in tuxedos.

  • sally

    I will definitely write a note. My mother grew up in Lebanon, Ind., to be a giving and open-hearted woman. She would be appalled at this pettiness.

  • Beth

    Diane Keaton wore men’s wear to the Oscars. Julia Roberts wore mens wear to the Golden Globes. Bianca Jagger wore a pants suit. Tatum O’Neal wore a Tuxedo to the Oscars….all of these women are heterosexuals. The HS not allowing this this girl to wear a tuxedo to the prom is doing so because they don’t want her there. There is no reason to ban a tuxedo. Clothing these days is unisex. Does the school ban boys from wearing earrings? I wish the school administrator courage and hope he does the right thing. This could be a real learning experience for the students and the community. How ironic that the school administrator is trying to censor this student, deny her her right to be who she is, and does not recognize how the school could be an example to the community of inclusion.

  • Ruth

    How many people have we hurt and offended because we judged their appearance, and in doing so have damaged a soul that only wants the freedom to be what it is? I have four cousins who are gay, one of which is an award winning writer of teen novels. What a shame it would be if she had been judged and refused publishing just because she is gay. We send our young women into the army in a “men’s” uniform. Female hockey players wear “men’s” equipment. I know this because I am a hockey player. And yes, I am on a team with gays and by association, I have been judged. There is so much hate and anger in this world, imagine the peace if we were inclusive and accepting of our differences. What a truly boring world this would be if we were all conformed to what is deemed as “right”. There is the saying, “don’t sweat the small stuff”. The issue of a female, gay or straight, choosing to wear a tuxedo, is really smaller than small and requires no judgment whatsoever. I hope the powers that be redirect their decision and allow this young girl to be herself, wear a tux, and have the time of her life at her well deserved prom. And, I hope that she has the strength to carry herself with pride and dignity after this unfortunate act of prejudice.

    I did write and as of yet it has not been returned. I am hopeful that Mr. O’Rourke will receive an email from Canada.

  • Amanda

    I am nearly 40 years old and at my senior prom, I remember one friend who wore a tux and no one said a discouraging word. This was at a catholic, all girls, private school in the south….what does that say about you, Mr. O’Rourke? Step into this century and treat your students with love.

  • Allyson

    Thank you, Patti, for continually standing up for the GLBT community. The world will be a better place for our children, gay and straight, by us speaking up every single time this sort of discrimination happens.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *